A dispute over whether it was too early to decide an outline application to build 45 houses in Four Marks dominated East Hampshire District Council’s planning committee meeting on November 19.
The council’s planning portal stated that the public consultation for the proposal for land next to Avon Lodge in Alton Lane - reference EHDC-26-0340-OUT - should continue until the end of the next day, November 20.
Dr Arthur Barlow, chair of Fight4FourMarks, said: “Why are we even here discussing this application? The public consultation for this application has not yet been closed.
“So if you make a decision tonight, you will be predetermining and otherwise exposing yourself to all kinds of legal issues. I would strongly suggest that the committee refuses to discuss this application until after the consultation has formally closed.”

Another outline application for Alton Lane, to build 88 houses on land west of Landport, was deferred.
Cllr Paul McAllister, of Four Marks Parish Council, said: “We welcome the deferral of the 88-home Landport scheme today over procedural compliance. Determining this application today is equally unsafe. While I cannot move a motion, we ask a voting committee member to move a formal motion to defer.
“Last night Four Marks Parish Council actively discussed pursuing a judicial review, including community crowd funding, if this application is approved today.”
The gov.uk website states: “The formal consultation period will normally last for 21 days.”
Ward district councillor Roland Richardson said: “I particularly draw your attention to the consultation date of November 20.
“I note in the yellow supplementary pages that this is a mix-up between the council and Natural England, but that's not the point. The point is it's on the website, it says that the consultation date for the public is November 20, so we shouldn't be deciding it today.”
Planning officer Richard Natt said: “In terms of the consultation period, that's sort of alluded to that that was an error. Natural England were consulted when the application was submitted. They've had 21 days to comment on the application, so naturally they were going to have been consulted on the application.
“They were reconsulted by error, inadvertently, and that has resulted in, on the website, the consultation date expiring tomorrow.”
Dr Barlow added: “Four Marks has been overburdened with so many new developments like this one, a massive expansion of the village with no new infrastructure. It won't be a village, but a dormitory town with inadequate services.
“When is the committee going to say enough is enough and dare to refuse this application? You have all the reasons you need.”
Cllr Richardson added: “I've made a deputation many times about the cumulative harm that is being done to Four Marks, Medstead and Chawton. Is this where we want to direct housing so that it can be delivered in a sustainable way with supporting infrastructure? We are at the whim of the developers.”
After debating for two hours and 20 minutes, and asking their legal team if it was safe to proceed with the consultation not having expired, the committee voted in favour of the application by nine votes to nil, with one abstention.
Find out about planning applications that affect you by visiting the Public Notice Portal.
To see more planning applications in your area visit publicnoticeportal.uk






Comments
We've recently changed our login process. If you have an account for commenting, you will need to re-register on the login window.
This article has no comments yet. Be the first to leave a comment.